“The Architecture Essay Writing Competition 2020” (TAEC) conducted by IDHA Labs was concluded with official result announcements made by an esteemed Jury panel, along with an opportunity for the winners to read out their essays. IDHA Labs also formally launched their blog of essays with the shortlisted entries. The result announcement session was a conclusion of the two-month-long evaluation period by the jury.
The jury panel was a team of eminent architects and writers in India- Apurva Bose Dutta, Gita Balakrishnan, Mrinalini Ghadiok, Madhavi Desai and Yatin Pandya. The panel was assisted by a team of Shortlisting Committee (SC) members to present the best scoring essays from which winners were picked.
The essay competition was announced on 1 September 2020 with briefs for Student and Professional categories. The participants had time until October 11, 2020, to submit, post which the SC was assigned with evaluations. The SC worked under the aegis of IDHA Labs to submit a shortlisted lot of essays to the Jury panel. The Panel worked then until last week of November and disclosed their decisions to IDHA Labs, which were published officially on November 29 2020.
The briefs of the competition
The competition was themed as “Space, Time and Architecture” applying to both professionals and students. It expects a discourse on the trends seen in spatial evolution across times. The student brief was titled “Approach to Architecture of India: Traditionalizing Modernity or Modernizing Traditionality”. The student’s brief asks the question of which would make a better choice between updating our traditions and recreating modernity with old wisdom. The first choice is expressed as Modernizing Traditionality while the second as Traditionalizing Modernity. Furthermore, the student’s brief is to discuss the challenges that our traditions have faced, while to also check if our traditions have given way to the modern. Besides, the student’s brief asks how/if we can embrace traditions and modernity, without comprising one for the other.
The professional’s brief titled “Cities Matter: Rethinking the Modern Urbanscapes of India” is to explore reimagination of modern urbanscapes in India, in alignment with what the 21st century expects. The brief prompts the professional entrants to think beyond the common talking points of planning, construction, aesthetics and material usage. While the student’s brief is bigger, it helps understand the framework within which he could work his essay. The professional’s brief is open to exploration thereby expecting more awareness with the participant.
The result announcement
The session was an hour-and-a-half program. The agenda began with introducing the competition’s goals to the different participants who tuned in to view the results and ask their questions to the jury. As a follow up the Jury panel shared their appreciation and views about the effort to promote the niche area of architectural writing.
The session’s principal moderator from IDHA Labs said that the competition successfully garnered the support of several participants with their entry submissions across the various Indian states. The aims of the competition were also to encourage and bring to light the creative and research possibilities of writing in architecture. Moreover, IDHA Labs also strove to establish a platform for students and professionals alike to test their capabilities and learn from a Pan-Indian competition. This is a checkpoint in their passion to teach and share with the younger lot in architecture in India. The principal moderator also expressed his gratitude to the Jury members who have extended their moral support to the IDHA Labs team. Besides, the volunteers were also appreciated for devoting their time and effort to assist.
As a follow-up, the Jury members shared their views and appreciation of IDHA Labs’ effort at this competition. Each of the jury members mentioned their thoughts on how important the activity of writing is within architecture. Particularly, Architect Yatin Pandya had put forth an analogy that architects functioning as writers have the space to act as advisors to different areas of professional practice, while also aiding with self-introspection. Architect Apurva Dutta had highlighted how there are growing visibility and advocacy for architectural writing and spoke her thoughts briefly on her experience as a writer herself. Architect Mrinalini Ghadiok expressed the importance that writing carries in terms of intellectual activity associated with it. Architects Madhavi Desai and Gita Balakrishnan had specified how delightful they felt reviewing the many participants that possessed a clarity of thought and writing skills in their essays.
The moderator of the question-and-answer period, from the Shortlisting Committee, had curated a few questions sent in from the participants to put forth to the Jury members in this session. The questions were about developing writing skills such as title framing, structuring of essays, research methodologies and more. The Jury members also provided insightful responses which made the session a good takeaway for the participants tuning in.
Following the question-and-answer period, the Jury was requested to announce the winners in both the student and professional categories, the participants of which read out their essays upon result declaration. Each of the Jury members also shared the qualities which helped these essays bag the prizes and also pointed at the few areas where the winners can improve their skills.
The winners
The Professional Category winners are Architects Shivani Pinapotu and Mihir Sriram, whose essay is titled “Are We Designing Smart Cities or Smart Looking Cities?”. The Jury members had mentioned that this essay had a well-built narrative around the arguments which the entrants expressed and that the same was structured very neatly. These features of this essay made it a very enjoyable and insightful read. Furthermore, this essay was said to have been a thought-provoking read too. Amongst the student entries, the winning essay was “Modernity: The Latest layer of Tradition”, written by student architect Yakin Kinger. The jury commended Yakin’s precise comprehension of the brief and his pragmatic response to it, which is exemplary at the student level.
The Professional Category winners are Architects Shivani Pinapotu and Mihir Sriram, whose essay is titled “Are We Designing Smart Cities or Smart Looking Cities?”
the student entries, the winning essay was “Modernity: The Latest layer of Tradition”, written by student architect Yakin Kinger.
The student category’s trophy was a tied victory. The prize was also won by the essay titled “Traditional and Modern: A Social Construct”, written by student architects Kayva P Krishnan and Malavika S Nair. The jury appreciated this essay for the intriguing reflections that were portrayed by the writers about the concepts mentioned in the brief, in addition to the way forward suggested in architectural design for the Indian context.
“Traditional and Modern: A Social Construct”, written by student architects Kayva P Krishnan and Malavika S Nair.
Jury Reviews on the Competition
As mentioned earlier, this competition was an effort to bring to light the creative allied field of writing within architecture. IDHA Labs has also taken similar initiatives before by organising competitions for Photography, sketching, illustrations and Product Design and more. Along these lines, an upcoming competition by IDHA Labs is the “NODE: Pavilion Design Challenge”.
Architect Yatin Pandya shared his testimonial that the competition was organised very meticulously with transparency for the more than 320 entries received. He also stated that such competitions with entries that display maturity and clarity can stimulate meaningful dialogues and exchanges within the fraternity. Architect Madhavi Desai had mentioned that the competition was very well curated and the entries displayed technically and conceptually sound knowledge and thought. Architect Apurva highlighted how the competition acknowledged the area of writing and that displayed the roles and responsibilities of design-planning-architecture by this skill.
Follow IDHA Labs to read all the shortlisted entries and for more details on their competitions.
All images © of IDHA Labs.
> via IDHA Labs.
This multi generational home is a testament to the ability of the design practice to blend aesthetic appeal with practical functionality. Keeping environmental sustainability and the welfare of the community at the forefront, Bhowal designed a home that was truly ahead of its time. His visionary approach and the Design Consortium’s expertise in providing a […]
In this modern luxury home, courtyards spill into living spaces, and the lines between inside and outside dissolve into a seamless whole. This 17,800 sq. ft. bungalow in Anand, by Hiren Patel Architects, blurs the boundaries between landscape, architecture, and interiors, creating a home where nature isn’t just the backdrop but an integral part of […]
Nestled in the foothills of the Shivalik range, the Himalayas is our latest project, Ekasham — a private residence refurbishment and redevelopment project, spread across an area of 2177 sqm. The monolithic home, through its volumes, composed of old and new structures, merges into a singular silhouette evoking the presence of a monolith from which […]
Ishaar is rooted in the belief that architecture should not just be seen, but deeply felt. Drawing from brutalist principles and natural tactility, the holiday villa is designed as a sensory retreat, where material, sound, light, and temperature shape the guest’s experience. Set amidst rural farmland, the villa dissolves into its landscape through a choreography […]
“Vishram Vaadi Nu Ghar” means a serene retreat amidst mango and chikoo farms, crafted to reflect the client’s vision in their mother tongue Gujarati. Vishram is a serene ground-touch structure offering breathtaking views of the Purna River and is a thoughtful example of countryside house design. Nestled amidst lush Amba and Chikoo Vaadi, the design […]
This single-story sustainable home in Ezhupunna blends traditional Kerala architecture with tropical, eco-friendly design. Inspired by the “kullakadavu” concept, a central pond encourages family interaction while enhancing the landscape. This Ezhupunna Home is Rooted in Eco-friendly Design | Judson Associates Architects & Interiors Despite being near lakes and beaches, adding a pond improves year-round moisture […]
In the heart of New Anjar, a small town tucked into the arid landscape of Kachchh, Gujarat, sits one of those modest houses designed with a quiet sense of clarity. Built for a Muslim family spanning three generations, the home isn’t trying to make a bold statement from its street-facing façade. Instead, it leans into […]
AME Studio was envisioned as a versatile yet understated architectural expression, reflecting our love for modest and unassuming architecture. AME Studio was envisioned as a versatile yet understated architectural expression, reflecting our love for modest and unassuming studio architecture. The design of AME Studio went beyond fulfilling a set of functional requirements; it was about […]
The house showcases a modern three-story residence exemplifying contemporary architectural design through its clean lines, geometric volumes, and a balanced interplay of materials. The facade skillfully combines textured tile cladding, smooth plaster, and contrasting color blocks in neutral shades of gray, black, and earthy rust, adding visual depth and dynamism. Expansive glass panels framed in […]
House of Silhouettes is located in Navratan, Udaipur. The plot is a corner one facing north and west 60’x40′ with a built-up area of 6500 sq.ft., designed in contemporary modern architecture as an independent house at three levels, including terrace. House of Silhouettes Reflects Contemporary Modern Architecture | Shaunak Singh and Associates This contemporary residence […]